Team Building - Collaborative vs. Competitive Team Building - Collaborative vs. Competitive

 by: Alan Hunt

Think back over all the team building sessions that you have attended over the years. There is a very good chance that at each and every one of them the facilitators organised your group into teams. Any that weren't were probably small groups. Sound familiar? Why do they do that?

Well, one answer is to encourage maximum involvement from the participants. Small team sizes help ensure that everyone joins in. Quieter people will be less likely to fade into the background the smaller the team they are in. But that's not the only - or even main - reason.

Most team building events are run as competitions. Teams are usually given identical goals and are awarded points as they move towards them. Points mean prizes and the winning team members get to take them away. Why?

There are a few answers to that one:

* Competitive events are relatively straightforward to run.

* Put a group of people into teams and it is easier to justify using the training budget.

* Competition generates a buzz.

* Many conferences are for sales people, who are naturally competitive.

If all of these factors are relevant to your conference, then a competitive event is probably a good decision for you. However, two factors might make it a less good decision. Organisations are increasingly looking to arrange events for non-sales functions and many of these see competition as a bad thing. Secondly, senior managers often prefer to stress the "one big team" approach as important to a large department or the organisation as a whole. If either or both of these are relevant to your group, then a competitive event is not the best choice.

The opposite of a competitive event is a collaborative one. The whole group is given a common goal to work on together rather than multiple, identical ones to work on in isolation. They may still be organised into teams or not, but the key characteristic is that everyone is collaborating with everyone else to achieve something as a whole group.

Options designed to be collaborative not only exist - they are among the most enjoyable conference or away day events for the participants themselves. They can deliver a superb mix of camaraderie, corporate message, learning and fun.

Isn't that combination a great outcome from a team building event? Indeed, isn't that an outcome that you want from your teams at work - day in, day out? Sure, you want your individual teams to aim to be the best - but not at the expense of the corporate goal or goals. You want the natural motivation that the best teams feel to be productive for the organisation - not detrimental to other teams and, thereby, detrimental to the organisation.

So what does a collaborative team building activity look like? I have written a number of other articles that describe the characteristics that you can expect to find in good options generally. Rather than duplicate them here, I shall concentrate on those elements that can focus on the collaborative aspect specifically. They are:

* There is a single, common goal that all individuals and / or teams have to work towards.

* There is a genuine possibility - indeed probability - of the group achieving it.

* Not all individuals and teams are doing the same thing - multiple, different functions is a feature of the workplace and needs to be a feature of a team activity if the learning is to be relevant.

* As at work, the participants need to exert some form of overall co-ordination to maintain the focus on the common goal.

So at your next team building event, don't send your people away bragging about how they managed to outdo their colleagues - send them away thinking at least in part how well they worked with them. Then maybe back at work something might just rub off.

Copyright 2006 Sandstone Limited

About The Author

Alan Hunt is Managing Director of Sandstone, a leading UK team building company. He enjoys creating innovative activities that combine fun with genuine team development. In his spare time, he does voluntary work for the RNIB.

http://www.sandstone.co.uk


Other professional employer services texas Items

Reference & Research Book News - Practical human resources management for public managers; a case study approach

December 1, 2011 --

Practical human resources management for public managers; a case study approach.

Valcik, Nicolas A. and Teodoro J. Benavides.

...


Business Wire - GEICO looking to hire 100 new employees in Dallas

November 8, 2011 --

DALLAS -- Even though GEICO’s office in Dallas employs roughly 1,200 associates, employee growth shows no signs of...


Alaska Business Monthly - GCI company lands Gulf of Mexico contract

November 1, 2011 --

GCI Industrial Telecom, a division of General Communication Inc., has been awarded a multiyear contract to provide on-call emergency...


Chain Drug Review - Quality, affordability are top of mind at H.E.B

August 29, 2011 --

SAN ANTONIO -- Staffed with health care professionals who ensure accuracy and quality, pharmacies operated by H-E-B strive to help patients...


Market Wire - Global Security Services, by G4S Secure Solutions (USA) Inc., a Feature of "Industry Today" on Industrialinfo.com

June 13, 2011 --

Industrial Info Resources (Sugar Land, Texas) will host special guest G4S Secure Solutions (USA) Inc. (Jupiter, Florida) as part of this...


Market Wire - Texas Playground Expert Terry O'Bannion Celebrates Second Anniversary With Commercial Playground Equipment Specialists All Play, Inc.

July 14, 2010 --

The parks and recreation professional credited with the development of the City of Houston's landmark maintenance program for its 260+ park...


Business Wire - Nonprofit Community Sharing Initiatives and Resolutions to Make 2010 Year of Recovery

December 1, 2009 -- HASH(0x1f1ae60)

AUSTIN, Texas -- The value and impact of America’s nonprofit community is immeasurable in ...


Business Wire - TPG Becomes an Inaugural Sponsor of SEO’s New Alternative Investment Fellowship Program to Promote Diversity in the Financial Community

October 28, 2009 -- HASH(0x2a966b6830)

FORT WORTH, Texas & NEW YORK -- TPG and nonprofit organization Sponsors for Educational...


Arkansas Business - ClearPointe buys TecWatch of Dallas

October 5, 2009 --

ClearPointe of Little Rock, an information technology services company, has bought TecWatch, an IT company in Dallas. Terms of the deal were...


Business Wire - Hospice Compassus Opens New Office in Houston Area; Marks Its Fourth in the Marketplace

August 24, 2009 -- HASH(0x2a966b12a0)

Location to Complement Company’s Local Area Presence with this North...